Skip to Content

What is WAR in Baseball? The Complete Guide

What is WAR in Baseball? The Complete Guide

You may wonder what WAR means in baseball. In another field of discussion, war means the absence of peace. But we are talking about a very different topic which is sports.

So in this article, let us discuss further what is WAR in baseball and the related topics we must tackle.

What is WAR in Baseball?

Baseball is made up of many elements and players may help their teams win by hitting, base running, defensive play, or pitching. The sabermetric baseball community has created a statistic called Wins Above Replacement (WAR) to summarize a player’s whole impact on their team in one number.

The WAR formula takes into account a player’s value in all elements of the game by comparing how many more wins he is worth than a replacement-level player at his position.

The system uses a simplified version of WAR to provide an approximation for the question, “If this player was injured and his team was forced to replace him with a freely available minor leaguer or an AAAA player from the bench, how much value would the squad be losing?”

WAR is not meant to be a precise indication of a player’s performance, but rather an approximation of their value to date. Given the flaws in some of the available data and the assumptions made to calculate other elements, WAR is best used as a rough estimate.

Although WAR is not as difficult as some belief, it does require a significant amount of data to compute and interpret.

The rWAR and the bWar

The numbers are not equivalent. There are two ways to compute fWAR: using FanGraphs (fWAR) and Baseball-Reference (rWAR or bWAR).

Replacement level is the average number of runs a team scores or allows, regardless of how many players are used. However, because they use different methods for calculating offensive, defensive, and pitching value, their conclusions vary in some cases.

The same concept is referred to as WARP in the game of baseball. Baseball-Prospectus calculates this statistic known as WARP, which is the same thing albeit under a different name.

Why use WAR?

The timeless question “How important is each player to his team?” is at the heart of WAR. Baseball is made up of numerous parts and individuals may help their teams win by hitting, running the bases, defensive play, or throwing.

  • Comparing players on the offensive is beneficial, but it overlooks a player’s potential defensive impact. It’s a simple method to combine a player’s entire contribution into a single number.
  • The purpose of WAR is to provide a comprehensive analysis of the player value that may be used to compare teams, leagues, individuals, eras, and seasons. While there will almost certainly be modifications to the method by which we calculate WAR’s inputs, the basic concept has long been a desire of fans and analysts alike.
  • WAR is a great way to measure your player’s value. It allows us to compare players with wildly different skill sets and see who performed best in certain circumstances! Is a first baseman who can hit for power better than a superb defensive shortstop?

These can be answered through WAR.

How is WAR Used?

How WAR is utilized is one of the more contentious aspects of sabermetrics. Given the complexity of the calculation and possible measurement errors, WAR should be used as a guideline for comparing groups of players rather than a precise figure.

  • To illustrate, a player that has been worth 6.4 wins over a season and a player who has been worth 6.1 wins may not be distinguished from one another using WAR. Because of the closeness, it is impossible to discern one from another. Although it’s easy to find out that these two players are roughly equivalent in value, you must dig deeper to distinguish them.
  • However, since a 6.4 WAR player and a 4.1 WAR player are distinct enough to give you confidence in the first player has been more important to his team during the season.
  • The most difficult point for position players in measuring defense and calculating the positional adjustment. Because our measures of both are more volatile than our measures of offense, players who get a substantial portion of their value from their defensive ratings have more uncertainty surrounding their WAR value than those that have defensive worth closer to average.
  • There is no denying that the statistic has been extremely accurate in predicting win-loss records, but it has yet to attain complete accuracy, and hence should be used as such.
  • The most important open question for pitchers is how much credit a pitcher should get for the outcome of a ball in play. We’re aware that there’s a degree of ability required to keep hits on balls in play at bay, but we have no way of quantifying it.
  • As a result, WAR will sell short players who can outperform FIP and will oversell those pitchers whose performance falls short of their FIP due to factors out of their hands. At this point, we don’t have a method of accurately attributing credit for balls in play.

Because it requires you to think more abstractly than other aspects of life, utilizing WAR correctly is tough. The specific number isn’t as significant as the basic range, but this isn’t just true in the case of WAR. This is true for all statistics in the game, whether it’s offense or defense.

What Variables are Included in the WAR Formula?

In a formula, WAR includes offensive, defensive, and base running contributions. The weights given to each category are determined by the sabermetric community after much debate.

Here are the variables needed:

  • Batting Runs (Rbat)
  • Grounded in Double Play Runs (Rdp)
  • Positional Adjustment Runs (Rpos)
  • Fielding Runs (Rdef)
  • Replacement Level Runs
  • Baserunning Runs (Rbr)

Batting Runs (Rbat)

For each position player, this number indicates how many runs superior or worse than average a hitter is. Because this figure is compared to a “typical” MLB player instead of a minor-league replacement level performer, many batters will be in deficit.

Grounded in Double Play Runs (Rdp)

How successful a player is in avoiding double plays is measured. When a player hits a ground ball where at least one out is recorded when there is a runner on first and less than two outs, this statistic is calculated by how many double plays he makes.

Positional Adjustment Runs (Rpos)

In essence, the positional adjustment is a fix to compensate for the fact that various occupations are more difficult than others, which isn’t much of a leap. A center fielder is significantly poorer than a first baseman.

Fielding Runs (Rdef)

The total number of runs prevented or earned by a player’s defense is known as his defensive effectiveness. This value is compared to an average defender at his position, so players who are stationed in more difficult positions will have lower numbers.

Replacement Level Runs

Replacement level is a term used in baseball to describe a player who contributes 17.5 runs fewer than an average player over 600 plate appearances. Replacement level players are those who are easy to acquire when a starter suffers an injury. These are the players who were not offered contracts at the start of the year or who are 6-year minor league free agents.

Baserunning Runs (Rbr)

Stolen bases and caught stealing are included in the calculation of wRAA. It also subtracts from the Non-Baserunning portion of the baserunning, which covers items such as first to third on singles, outs on the bases, tagging up on fly balls, and scoring from third on a ground ball.

What is WAR in Baseball? The Complete Guide

A Replacement Level Player in Baseball

Replacement-level players are easy to acquire when a starter goes down, as they’re part of the regular rotation. These are the players who were not invited to spring training at the beginning of the season or those who are 6-year minor league free agents.

Replacement level is an important term in sabermetrics or the statistical study of baseball. This is because Major League Baseball teams are not allowed to have a roster of 40 players, so the management has to decide which players will be in uniform on any given day.

When a player is roughly 20% better than replacement-level, he’s considered an average player. When a player is 40% better than an outright replacement, he’s considered an All-Star.

The replacement level is where the majority of players in Major League Baseball fall under, so this term is used to identify these players. It can be used to describe specific aspects of a player, such as his fielding or hitting skills, but not others like leadership or motivation.

What Makes a Replacement Level Player Get in the Game?

It’s the question that everyone asks, but few have answered. What makes a replacement-level player in baseball?

Those are:

1. Players that are freely available to sign, and sign relatively inexpensively. These players could be signed by any MLB team without compensation being sent back from the said team(s).

2. Players that have been designated for assignment, players that have been outrighted to the minors or released by their current teams. Sometimes a player is passed through waivers unclaimed, and then they belong in this category, too.

3. Minor leaguers that have never reached 100 AB or 50 IP in any given MLB season.

4. Players on their first or second MLB Disabled List stints (i.e., not including short DL stints) with a clear indication from the team that they won’t be recalled until at least 10 days have passed.

5. Players that are signed to Minor League contracts with invitations to MLB Spring Training camps, but aren’t either roster-exempt or able to be sent outright to the minors without first clearing waivers themselves.

6. Players on their first MLB Disabled List stint (i.e., including short DL stints).

7. Players that are signed to Minor League contracts without invitations to Spring Training because of poor past performance or injury histories in the prior seasons and/or a strong indication from the team that they won’t compete for a roster spot in MLB at all during Spring Training.

8. Players that have been suspended for banned substances or illegal acts.

9. Players that are currently on the MLB Bereavement/Family Medical Emergency List or MLB Paternity Leave List due to their family-related issues (i.e., bereavements, births of children, etc…).

These players will not be added to a team’s 40-man roster during the offseasons or trade deadlines.

Is WAR Formula Helpful in Baseball?

WAR or Wins Above Replacement Player measures a player’s contribution to their team and is an excellent way for teams in baseball to calculate who deserves to stay or be replaced.

WAR is one of the most accurate, context-neutral statistics available to be utilized in evaluating players and player performance. With its present trajectory, it’s only a matter of time until WAR takes over MVP and Hall of Fame debates.

The VALUE statistic evaluates a player’s value in all aspects of the game by determining how many more wins he is worth than a replacement-level player at his position. For example: A typical full-time position player is worth about 2 WAR, while bench players contribute far less; often between 0 and 1 WAR. The average starting pitcher is worth around 2 WAR, while relief pitchers are deemed exceptional if they achieve +1 WAR.

How to Stay at the Top of the Baseball Game with WAR

If you are a baseball player and you don’t want to qualify for replacement, you should know something about Wins Above Replacement (WAR). Many draft pick decisions are made based on this statistic.

It’s also widely used by managers and the media to evaluate the contribution of ballplayers, but it’s an unproven tool that many people misunderstand or use improperly.

Here are tips to stay on top:

1. Know your WAR(s)

There are many different WARs available. FanGraphs, Baseball-Reference and Baseball Prospectus all have a version of this statistic that they use to rank players. You can find a full explanation of each one here:

Each site calculates their WAR differently, so the numbers will vary. As described above, there are also many different versions of WAR. Each version is appropriate for a different use, so you should know which one your team or the media outlet using WAR uses.

2. Know the context of your WAR

The average fielding range of your league and which position you play determines how to best use your WAR. When you read or hear about WAR, you will need to know if it is a positional average (meaning that all players at a particular position are stacked up against each other) or an overall average (all players are ranked against each other).

The positional average is better for evaluating how valuable a player was to their specific team. The overall WAR value helps you understand how good of a player they are in comparison to others in the league.

3. Know the context of your replacement level

The WAR value of a player can be compared to average players at that position or in the league as a whole, but it’s also useful to know what an average player would contribute relative to a freely available one. This is important in keeper and dynasty leagues where you might not want to pay market value for a player because you can get someone similar at a lower price.

If the WAR is just presented without any context or qualifiers, then it’s being used as an overall value of that player compared to all players in baseball.

4. Use common sense

This should be rule #1, but there are many situations where WAR doesn’t work.

  • Don’t use a player’s WAR to evaluate how good their team is. This is especially true when the players’ positions are stacked against each other, such as catcher or pitcher.
  • Don’t use a player’s WAR to compare players from different positions. For instance, you can’t say that Manny Machado is better than Mike Trout based on their WARs.
  • Keep in mind that the defensive component of WAR is imperfect and incomplete.

5. Know your history

The more information on players you can access, the better you will be able to use WAR as an evaluation tool for your specific league settings. If you can’t find a statistic back to the year you are interested in, you will have to estimate it.

Estimating WAR is difficult because many factors go into it. But if you can’t find an answer for your league or era, then use a similar player to help guide your judgment. It won’t be perfect but it should be better than random guessing.

The Disadvantage of Using WAR in Baseball Statistics

WAR is a statistic that purports to show how much better or worse a baseball player is than the average player at his position. It also takes into account many other variables, such as stolen bases and sacrifice bunts. For this article, WAR will be used as an indicator of value, not as a definitive statistic.

The idea of WAR is widely accepted in the sabermetrics community, but it has its detractors. Some people say that it can’t be calculated without knowing how much better one player is than the next best alternative at his position. Others say that it has no predictive value. Still, others will say, “WAR is a simplification of several variables into a single number.”

The main problem with WAR as a statistic is that there are too many ways to calculate it.

1. First of all, the defensive component varies depending on what you count as being included in defense.

2. Two of the offensive components are batting average and on-base percentage, but at least three others could be used instead, including slugging percentage, OPS, wOBA (weighted On Base Average), or Total Batting Average.

3. Three variables are assigned to baserunning – stolen bases, caught stealing, and taking the extra base – but if you are using three variables, why not just have a statistic that measures baserunning?

4. One of the variables is games started, even though it doesn’t really measure anything. Why not just use innings pitched or plate appearances?

5. Finally, there are different ways to adjust for defensive contributions depending on the positions and how defensive replacements are used.

Why is Baseball Player Statistics Important?

Many look into statistics as a guide to determine who the best player is in a certain sport. It gives an objective comparison that even the fans can understand. For this reason, stats plays huge role in Baseball especially in Major League Baseball (MLB).

A quick look at the record book of MLB will show just how important it is when you see names like Babe Ruth, Roger Maris, and Hank Aaron. There are so many other important records which we can’t even mention here because of lack of space.

Every MLB season, there will be a close race for the most coveted record in Baseballs such as home runs or batting average. This is because these two particular stats have been kept track throughout the years and therefore, it has become the benchmark for the greatness of a player.

Therefore, how does one go about finding these players who are trying to make history?

First, you need to know some basics behind statistics and why Baseball stats are important.

Here’s what you’ll need to know:

  • What is the definition of batting average (BA), wins (W), ERA (E.R.A.) and other great Baseball stats?
  • What are some of the best Baseball stats to use when determining the greatness of a player?
  • What is Sabermetrics?
  • How can it make my life easier as a baseball fan?
  • What is BABIP, FIP, WAR, OPS, etc?

The best way to start this discussion is by defining some of the basic stats in Baseball so you will get an idea of why they are important.

  • Batting Average ( BA ) – It is the ratio of several hits to a total number of at-bats.
  • On-Base Percentage ( OBP ) – It is a measure of how many times a batter reaches base safely.
  • Runs batted in ( RBI ) – It is the sum of all runs that are driven in by a batter.
  • Earned Run Average ( ERA ) – It measures how many earned runs pitcher allows per nine innings.
  • On-base plus slugging ( OPS ) – It is a simple way to combine a batters OBP and SLG.
  • WAR or Wins Above Replacement – It measures how many additional wins that a player contributed to his team.
  • Wins ( W ) – It measures how many games that a pitcher won during the season.

Now, you know some of the most basic baseball stats which are very crucial in determining the greatness of a player.

What is WAR in Baseball? The Complete Guide


With the help of WAR, it will be easier to determine the best players in MLB. The major issue with the WAR statistic is that it has too many variables to calculate. However, overall, it is still the best statistic that we have to determine a player’s value.

Other Posts: